Published November 17, 2026.
The call usually comes from the school first, not the police. A dean has a screenshot. By the time a parent gets to campus, the school resource officer has already interviewed the student, and the charge being discussed is a second-degree felony, the same grade as aggravated battery. Most families have never heard of section 836.10 until that afternoon. What it covers, what the state actually has to prove, and what the next 24 hours look like in Broward or Palm Beach juvenile court are below.
The Short Version
- Section 836.10 makes it a second-degree felony to send, post or transmit a writing or electronic record that contains a threat to kill, do bodily harm, or conduct a mass shooting or act of terrorism. The maximum in adult court is 15 years.
- The statute does not require the person to intend to carry out the threat. It does require the state to prove the person sent it as a threat or knew it would be viewed as one.
- “Posting” has been read broadly. Leaving a threatening note where a teacher could see it was enough for probable cause in one Florida appellate case.
- Most students are charged in juvenile court. For 16- and 17-year-olds, prosecutors have discretion to file any felony in adult court when they decide the public interest requires it.
- A felony arrest of a minor can be made public. Florida law allows law enforcement to release the name and photo of a juvenile charged with a felony.
- Every case is different. A result in one case does not predict the result in another.
In this article
What Section 836.10 Prohibits
Florida’s written threats statute makes it unlawful for any person to send, post or transmit, or procure the sending, posting or transmission of, a writing or other record, including an electronic record, in any manner in which it may be viewed by another person, when the writing contains a threat to kill or do bodily harm to another person, or to conduct a mass shooting or an act of terrorism. A violation is a second-degree felony. (section 836.10)
Three features of the statute drive most school cases.
- It covers electronic records. The definition includes anything created, modified, archived, received or distributed electronically. A Snapchat story, a Discord message, a text, a TikTok comment and a typed note on a school laptop all qualify. A telephone call does not.
- It covers threats to the public, not only a named person. Since the 2018 amendment, a threat to conduct a mass shooting or act of terrorism is covered even if no individual is named. Since the 2021 amendment, posting where it “may be viewed by another person” is enough; the threat no longer has to be sent directly to the target.
- It is a second-degree felony with no lesser tier. There is no misdemeanor version. In adult court the maximum is 15 years in prison and a $10,000 fine under sections 775.082 and 775.083.
Arrests under this section are now a weekly event during the school year. In 2026 South Florida cases included a student arrested for online threats against Nova Middle School in Davie and a 14-year-old charged after a group-chat message that said not to come to school. (WSVN; News4Jax) Threat-monitoring software on school-issued devices now generates alerts that go straight to the school resource officer. The students in these reports are presumed innocent; an arrest is an allegation.
The “I Was Joking” Question
Almost every student in these cases says the same thing: it was a joke, or trash talk in a game chat, or a dark meme. Whether that matters is the central legal question, and the answer has changed in the last few years.
The statute does not require proof that the person intended to carry out the threat. Florida courts have said that for decades. What the state must now prove is the person’s state of mind about the message itself. In T.R.W. v. State, the Fourth District Court of Appeal, which covers Broward and Palm Beach, held that section 836.10 includes a mens rea element: the state must prove the defendant sent the communication for the purpose of issuing a threat, or with knowledge that it would be viewed as a threat. The trial judge in that case had ruled the juvenile’s intent was irrelevant. The appellate court reversed and sent the case back. (T.R.W. v. State, Fla. 4th DCA 2023)
Months later, the United States Supreme Court reached a similar place in Counterman v. Colorado, holding that the First Amendment requires at least recklessness: the speaker must have consciously disregarded a substantial risk that the communication would be viewed as threatening violence. (Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023))
So “I was joking” is not a complete defense, and it is not irrelevant either. The question is what the student understood about how the message would land. A line in a private chat between two friends who had been trading insults for an hour sits differently from a post naming a school and a date. What decides these cases is everything around the message: who received it, what came before it in the thread, what the student said in the dean’s office, and what was found on the phone or in a notebook afterward. Prosecutors in the Seventeenth Circuit have been willing to look at that context when it is put in front of them early. They do not go looking for it on their own.
What Counts as Sending or Posting
Before 2021, several cases were reversed because the threat was never sent to the person threatened. In J.A.W. v. State, the Second District reversed a juvenile’s adjudication for tweets that were not sent to any victim. (J.A.W. v. State, Fla. 2d DCA 2016) The Legislature responded by adding “post” and “in any manner in which it may be viewed by another person.”
Courts have since read that language broadly. In N.H. v. State, a student left a paper on her desk with the word “Kill” followed by two teachers’ last names; a teacher saw it. The Fifth District held that “post” takes its ordinary meaning, which covers displaying a writing where others can see it, and that leaving the note openly on a classroom desk was enough for probable cause. One judge dissented, reasoning that posting requires an affirmative act of communication. (N.H. v. State, Fla. 5th DCA 2023)
The practical lesson is that privacy settings and intended audience are evidence, not a shield. A message in a 14-person group chat has been “posted.” A story visible to friends has been “posted.” Whether the student meant it as a threat is a separate question, and that is where the T.R.W. standard comes in.
Juvenile Court, Adult Court and Direct File
Most students charged under section 836.10 are handled in juvenile court under chapter 985. The vocabulary is different: a petition for delinquency instead of an information, an adjudication instead of a conviction, a disposition instead of a sentence. The possible outcomes range from diversion and probation to commitment to a Department of Juvenile Justice residential program.
Two things make these cases more serious than many parents expect.
- Detention. After a felony arrest a juvenile is scored on a risk assessment instrument and may be held in secure detention, at the regional juvenile detention center, until a detention hearing that must happen within 24 hours. In the N.H. case the student was released to her mother on home supervision rather than held, but that is a judge’s call on each set of facts, and a parent who shows up to that hearing with counsel is in a different position than one who does not.
- Direct file. Under section 985.557, the State Attorney may file adult charges against a 14- or 15-year-old only for a list of specific offenses, mostly violent crimes, and written threats is not among them. For a 16- or 17-year-old, the State Attorney may file any felony in adult court when the public interest requires adult sanctions, with no offense-specific limit. Whether that discretion is used depends on the office, the facts and the student’s history. (section 985.557)
The difference between a juvenile disposition and an adult felony conviction is the difference between a record that can be sealed or expires and one that follows a person into every job and apartment application. Keeping the case in juvenile court, and keeping it out of a residential commitment, is often the first objective.
Consequences Beyond the Courtroom
- Public identification. Under section 985.04, the name, photograph, address and arrest report of a child taken into custody for an act that would be a felony are not confidential solely because of the child’s age. Some sheriffs’ offices publish them as policy, and the posts stay online. (section 985.04)
- Expulsion. School districts handle threats under their own codes of conduct, separately from the criminal case. An expulsion hearing can happen before the criminal case is resolved, and statements made there can be used later.
- Firearm consequences. A felony adjudication affects firearm rights for the student and can trigger a risk protection order affecting the household.
- Cost recovery. At least one Florida sheriff has publicly said parents would be billed for the cost of investigating a hoax threat. Whether that is enforceable is a separate legal question, but it signals how aggressively these cases are being pursued.
Where a Defense Begins
- Who sent it. Shared accounts, borrowed phones and screenshots with no metadata are common. In one 2026 case, police first contacted the student whose app account sent the threat and then determined another student had used it. (WWSB) Device forensics and account records matter.
- State of mind. Under T.R.W. and Counterman, the state must prove the student sent the message as a threat or knew, or at least consciously disregarded a substantial risk, that it would be seen as one. Context, the full conversation, and the student’s immediate reaction are evidence on this point.
- Was it a threat at all. A statement has to contain a threat to kill, do bodily harm, or conduct a mass shooting or act of terrorism. Vague anger, song lyrics and game-chat language have been litigated, and not every alarming message meets the statute.
- How the statement was obtained. Students are often questioned by a school resource officer with an administrator present before a parent is called. Whether the student was in custody, whether Miranda warnings were required, and whether a parent’s absence affects voluntariness are all live issues in juvenile cases.
- Diversion. For a first offense with no weapon, no plan and no prior record, juvenile diversion or a civil citation may be available. Eligibility is decided early, and the way the case is first presented to the State Attorney affects it.
What Parents Should Do Right Away
- Do not let your child be interviewed again by police or school officials without a lawyer. You can say this politely and it ends the questioning.
- Do not delete anything. Deleting messages, accounts or devices can be charged as tampering with evidence and looks worse than the original post.
- Preserve the full conversation. Screenshot the entire thread, including what came before and after, from your child’s device. Context is the defense.
- Write down the timeline of who contacted you, when, and what was said.
- Ask about the detention hearing. If your child is being held, a hearing must happen within 24 hours. Be there with counsel.
- Call a lawyer before the school hearing. The expulsion process and the criminal case affect each other.
Questions and Answers
Is threatening a school shooting a felony in Florida?
Yes. Sending, posting or transmitting a writing or electronic record that threatens to conduct a mass shooting or act of terrorism is a second-degree felony under section 836.10, punishable in adult court by up to 15 years in prison. (section 836.10)
Can my child be charged if it was a joke?
A student can be arrested and charged. Whether the state can prove the case depends on showing the student sent the message as a threat or knew it would be viewed as one. (T.R.W. v. State) “It was a joke” is evidence on that question, not an automatic dismissal.
Does a Snapchat or group chat count as “posting”?
Yes. The statute covers any electronic record transmitted in any manner in which it may be viewed by another person. Florida courts have treated messages to friends, group chats and even a note left on a desk as covered.
Will my child be tried as an adult?
Most are not. For 14- and 15-year-olds, section 985.557 limits adult direct file to a list of specific offenses that does not include written threats. For 16- and 17-year-olds, the State Attorney may file any felony in adult court when the public interest requires it. Early involvement of counsel is aimed at keeping the case in juvenile court.
Can the sheriff publish my child’s name and photo?
Under section 985.04, those records are not confidential solely because of the child’s age once the child is taken into custody for an act that would be a felony. Some agencies publish them routinely; a records custodian may choose not to post booking photos online.
Is Your Child Facing a Written Threats Charge?
What you do in the first days matters. Call Alan S. Bernstein P.A. for a free, confidential consultation about a section 836.10 or juvenile felony case in Broward, Miami-Dade, Palm Beach, Martin and Hendry counties.
Weekdays 954-925-3111 | Evenings and weekends 954-347-1000
Sources
- Florida Statutes (2026): section 836.10 (written or electronic threats); section 985.557 (direct filing); section 985.04 (juvenile records); section 775.082 and section 775.083 (penalties).
- T.R.W. v. State, Nos. 4D21-2396, 4D21-2398, 4D21-2399 (Fla. 4th DCA Feb. 15, 2023); N.H. v. State, No. 5D23-795 (Fla. 5th DCA Mar. 27, 2023); J.A.W. v. State (Fla. 2d DCA 2016).
- Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023).
- WSVN, Student arrested after allegedly making online threats against Nova Middle School; News4Jax, Palm Coast High student accused of threatening to shoot up school on Snapchat (Apr. 28, 2026); WWSB, Manatee High student arrested after allegedly threatening staff (Sept. 1, 2026).
- Related reading on this site: Florida’s Deepfake and Altered Sexual Depiction Laws; Online Solicitation of a Minor in Florida.
This article is general information about Florida law as of November 17, 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every person charged with a crime is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. Every case is different. A result in one case does not predict the result in another.
Comment (1)
Resisting Officer Without Violence Florida: 843.02 Explained
says November 17, 2026 at 2:02 pm[…] reading on this site: Written Threats Charges Against Florida Students; How bond and charging decisions work in a Florida felony […]
Comments are closed.