Published November 17, 2026. Statutory text quoted from the 2026 Florida Statutes; case language quoted from the published opinions.
A dealing in stolen property charge in South Florida usually starts at a counter. Someone sells a phone, a power tool or a watch at a pawnshop in Hollywood or Lauderhill, the shop uploads the transaction to law enforcement that night, and a detective matches the serial number to a burglary report. The seller is then charged not with theft but with a second-degree felony that carries up to 15 years. This article sets out what the statute actually says, the three shortcuts the law gives prosecutors, the rule that stops the state from convicting a person of both theft and dealing for the same property, and the questions that decide these cases.
The Short Version
- Dealing in stolen property under section 812.019(1) is trafficking, or endeavoring to traffic, in property a person “knows or should know” was stolen. It is a second-degree felony. Organizing or financing the theft and then trafficking the goods is a first-degree felony under section 812.019(2).
- “Traffic” includes selling, transferring or disposing of property, and also buying, receiving or possessing it with intent to sell. One pawn ticket can be enough.
- Section 812.022 lets a jury infer knowledge from possession of recently stolen property, from a price substantially below market value, or from a dealer buying outside the regular course of business, “unless satisfactorily explained.”
- Section 812.025 lets the state charge theft and dealing together, but the jury “may return a guilty verdict on one or the other, but not both.” The Florida Supreme Court has held juries must be told this.
- Giving a pawnbroker false verification of ownership is a separate felony under section 539.001, and it is frequently charged alongside dealing.
- Every case is different. A result in one case does not predict the result in another.
In this article
What Section 812.019 Says
The whole offense is two sentences long. Here is the statute, word for word:
“(1) Any person who traffics in, or endeavors to traffic in, property that he or she knows or should know was stolen shall be guilty of a felony of the second degree, punishable as provided in ss. 775.082, 775.083, and 775.084.”
“(2) Any person who initiates, organizes, plans, finances, directs, manages, or supervises the theft of property and traffics in such stolen property shall be guilty of a felony of the first degree, punishable as provided in ss. 775.082, 775.083, and 775.084.”
Three things in that text drive almost every case. First, the crime is complete on an attempt: “endeavors to traffic” is in the statute, so a sale that never closes still counts. Second, the mental state is “knows or should know,” which is lower than actual knowledge. Third, subsection (2) is aimed at the person who ran the theft, not the person at the counter, and it doubles the maximum sentence.
The Florida Supreme Court described the difference between the two kinds of defendant this way: the question is “whether the defendant is a common thief who steals property with the intent to appropriate said property to his own use or to the use of a person not entitled to the use of the property or whether the defendant traffics or endeavors to traffic in the stolen property.” (Williams v. State, 125 So. 3d 113 (Fla. 2013), quoting Hall v. State, 826 So. 2d 268, 271 (Fla. 2002).)
What “Traffic” Means
“Traffic” sounds like an operation. The statutory definition is much broader than that, and it is why a single pawn transaction or a single Facebook Marketplace listing can support the charge:
“‘Traffic’ means: (a) To sell, transfer, distribute, dispense, or otherwise dispose of property. (b) To buy, receive, possess, obtain control of, or use property with the intent to sell, transfer, distribute, dispense, or otherwise dispose of such property.”
Paragraph (b) is the part people do not expect. Possessing stolen property with intent to sell it is trafficking under Florida law even if no buyer ever appears. In practice the state proves that intent with the listing, the text messages, the pawn ticket, or the quantity (twenty sealed phones in a trunk are hard to explain as personal use).
“Knows or Should Know” and the Three Inferences
The state rarely has a witness who heard the defendant say the goods were stolen. The Legislature solved that problem for prosecutors in section 812.022, which creates inferences a jury may draw. Each one carries the same escape hatch: “unless satisfactorily explained.”
“(2) Except as provided in subsection (5), proof of possession of property recently stolen, unless satisfactorily explained, gives rise to an inference that the person in possession of the property knew or should have known that the property had been stolen.”
“(3) Proof of the purchase or sale of stolen property at a price substantially below the fair market value, unless satisfactorily explained, gives rise to an inference that the person buying or selling the property knew or should have known that the property had been stolen.”
“(4) Proof of the purchase or sale of stolen property by a dealer in property, out of the regular course of business or without the usual indicia of ownership other than mere possession, unless satisfactorily explained, gives rise to an inference that the person buying or selling the property knew or should have known that it had been stolen.”
What these inferences mean at trial is that the state can rest its knowledge element on circumstances: how soon after the burglary the item was pawned, what the shop paid against what the item retails for, whether a buyer asked for a receipt. What they do not do is relieve the state of its burden. An inference is permissive, not mandatory, and the phrase “unless satisfactorily explained” puts the explanation squarely in play. A man who bought a generator from a neighbor at a yard sale and later pawned it has an explanation. Whether it is satisfactory is the jury’s call, which is why the facts around the acquisition matter more than anything else in the file.
Two points of caution from the defense side. “Recently stolen” is not defined by a number of days, and courts have treated the question as one of fact that depends on the type of property. And the inference in subsection (2) applies to any person in possession, not only to a dealer, so a person caught with a stolen item they intended to sell can face the inference even without any sale.
Why You Cannot Be Convicted of Both Theft and Dealing
Prosecutors in Broward and Miami-Dade routinely file theft and dealing in stolen property as separate counts for the same item. The statute allows that. It also says what the jury can do with it:
“Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a single indictment or information may, under proper circumstances, charge theft and dealing in stolen property in connection with one scheme or course of conduct in separate counts that may be consolidated for trial, but the trier of fact may return a guilty verdict on one or the other, but not both, of the counts.”
The Florida Supreme Court has enforced that sentence twice in ways that matter to a defendant today. In Hall v. State, the Court held that the rule binds the judge at a plea as much as a jury at trial: “Just as the trier of fact must make a choice if the defendant goes to trial, so too must the trial judge make a choice if the defendant enters a plea of nolo contendere to both counts.” (Hall, 826 So. 2d at 271, as quoted in Williams.) The Court explained why: “The linchpin of section 812.025 is the defendant’s intended use of the stolen property.”
In Williams v. State (2013), the Court went further and held that juries have to be told about the rule: “Simply put, the fact-finder must be aware that it cannot convict a defendant of both dealing in stolen property and theft ‘in connection with one scheme or course of conduct.'” The holding is direct: “we conclude that trial courts have an obligation to instruct the jury on section 812.025 when both theft and dealing in stolen property counts are submitted to the jury.” (Williams v. State, 125 So. 3d 113 (Fla. 2013).)
Why this is more than a technicality: when a jury is properly instructed, it has to decide which kind of defendant is in front of it. A person who stole a laptop for their own use and later sold it when money got tight has a real argument that the theft count, a third-degree felony or a misdemeanor depending on value, is the right one, and that the 15-year dealing count is not. Without the instruction the jury simply convicts on both and the judge keeps the greater charge. That is exactly what happened to Mr. Williams at trial before the Supreme Court took the case. The same statute also means the “scheme or course of conduct” language has to be analyzed: if the state’s theory is one episode, the choice must be made; if the state can prove the theft and the sale were separate schemes, it may argue the bar does not apply.
Pawnshops, Transaction Forms and the Second Charge
Most dealing cases in South Florida come out of pawnshops because the paperwork makes them easy to build. Under the Florida Pawnbroking Act, every pawn or purchase is recorded on a pawnbroker transaction form that must include, among other things, “The date and time of the transaction” and “The type of identification accepted from the pledgor or seller, including the issuing agency and the identification number,” along with the seller’s thumbprint. The form also contains “A statement that the pledgor or seller of the item represents and warrants that it is not stolen, that it has no liens or encumbrances against it, and that the pledgor or seller is the rightful owner of the goods and has the right to enter into the transaction.” (section 539.001(8), Florida Statutes (2026).)
Pawnbrokers must then “deliver to the appropriate law enforcement official the original printed pawnbroker transaction forms or printed copies of the digital pawnbroker transaction forms for each of the transactions occurring during the previous business day,” and most shops in Broward, Miami-Dade and Palm Beach transmit the records electronically. (section 539.001(9).) That is why a serial-number match can produce an arrest weeks after the transaction with no investigation beyond a database query.
The warranty on the form creates the second charge. The statute provides that “Any person who knowingly gives false verification of ownership or gives a false or altered identification and who receives money from a pawnbroker for goods sold or pledged commits,” if the money received is less than $300, “a felony of the third degree,” and if it is $300 or more, “a felony of the second degree.” (section 539.001(8)(b)8.) Signing the form while pawning someone else’s property is, in the state’s view, a separate crime from dealing, and it is charged as one. The defendant in Williams was convicted of exactly that combination: dealing in stolen property, burglary, and providing false information to a pawnbroker.
Penalties
| Charge | Degree | Maximum prison | Maximum fine |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dealing in stolen property, s. 812.019(1) | Second-degree felony | 15 years | $10,000 |
| Organizing/financing theft and trafficking, s. 812.019(2) | First-degree felony | 30 years | $10,000 |
| False verification of ownership to pawnbroker, $300 or more, s. 539.001(8)(b)8.b | Second-degree felony | 15 years | $10,000 |
| False verification of ownership to pawnbroker, under $300, s. 539.001(8)(b)8.a | Third-degree felony | 5 years | $5,000 |
Maximums come from sections 775.082 and 775.083. Dealing in stolen property is a Level 5 offense on the Criminal Punishment Code scoresheet, which means a first offender with no other points typically faces a non-state-prison sanction as a matter of scoring, but prior record, victim injury and additional counts change that quickly. Section 775.084 also allows habitual offender sentencing for people with qualifying priors. None of this is automatic, and a scoresheet should be reviewed line by line before any plea discussion.
Where a Defense Begins
The structure of the statute tells you where the fights are.
Knowledge. The state will lean on the section 812.022 inferences. The answer is the explanation the statute itself invites: where the property came from, what was paid for it, whether the price was actually below market for a used item in that condition, and whether the defendant did anything a person who knew the goods were stolen would not do, such as using their own ID and thumbprint at a licensed pawnshop two miles from home. People who know property is stolen do not usually hand over their driver’s license to sell it.
Trafficking. Possession alone is not dealing. The state needs a sale, transfer, or possession with intent to sell. Where the item was found in a car or a house with no listing, no messages and no buyer, the proper charge, if any, may be theft or possession-based, not section 812.019.
Section 812.025. If the information charges theft and dealing for the same property, the jury must be instructed under Williams, and the defense gets to argue which count fits. In a plea posture, Hall means the court cannot adjudicate both.
Identity and the chain. A serial-number match proves the item was stolen at some point. It does not prove who stole it or that the seller knew. The time between the theft and the pawn, intervening possessors, and how the victim identified the property are all open questions.
Value. The pawnbroker count turns on money received, and the dealing count often rides along with a theft count whose degree depends on value. Retail price, replacement price and fair market value of a used item are not the same number.
What to Do After an Arrest
Do not go back to the pawnshop, do not contact the person the property allegedly belongs to, and do not try to explain the purchase to the detective by phone. The explanation the statute allows is one that should be made with counsel, with documents, at the right time. Save every message, receipt, listing and payment record that shows how the item came into your possession, and write down who was present when you got it. If you received a pawn-hold notice or a letter from a detective, bring it to the first meeting.
Questions and Answers
Is dealing in stolen property a felony in Florida?
Yes. Under section 812.019(1), trafficking or endeavoring to traffic in property a person knows or should know was stolen is a second-degree felony, punishable by up to 15 years in prison. Organizing or financing the theft and trafficking the goods is a first-degree felony under section 812.019(2), punishable by up to 30 years.
Can I be charged with dealing in stolen property if I didn’t steal it?
Yes. The statute reaches anyone who traffics in property they know or should know was stolen. Who stole it is a separate question. The state must still prove that you sold, transferred or possessed the property with intent to sell it, and that you knew or should have known it was stolen.
What does “should know” mean?
It is an objective standard: what a reasonable person in the defendant’s position would have understood from the circumstances. Section 812.022 lets a jury infer knowledge from possession of recently stolen property, a price substantially below fair market value, or a dealer’s purchase outside the regular course of business, in each case “unless satisfactorily explained.”
Can I be convicted of both grand theft and dealing in stolen property for the same item?
Not when they arise from one scheme or course of conduct. Section 812.025 says the trier of fact “may return a guilty verdict on one or the other, but not both,” and the Florida Supreme Court held in Williams v. State (2013) that juries must be instructed on this rule. Under Hall v. State (2002), a judge taking a plea must also choose one.
Why was I also charged with giving false information to a pawnbroker?
Every pawnbroker transaction form contains a warranty that the seller owns the goods. Under section 539.001(8)(b)8, knowingly giving false verification of ownership and receiving money from a pawnbroker is a third-degree felony if the money received is under $300 and a second-degree felony if it is $300 or more.
How did the police find the pawn transaction?
Florida pawnbrokers must deliver transaction records, including the seller’s identification and thumbprint, to law enforcement for each previous business day, and most do so electronically. Detectives search those records by serial number and description when a theft is reported.
Charged With Dealing in Stolen Property in South Florida?
The explanation the statute allows should be made with counsel, not on the phone with a detective. Call Alan S. Bernstein P.A. for a free, confidential consultation about a dealing in stolen property, grand theft or pawnbroker charge in Broward, Miami-Dade, Palm Beach, Martin and Hendry counties.
Weekdays 954-925-3111 | Evenings and weekends 954-347-1000
Sources
- Florida Statutes (2026): section 812.019 (dealing in stolen property); section 812.012(8) (definition of “traffic”); section 812.022 (inferences); section 812.025 (charging theft and dealing); section 539.001 (Florida Pawnbroking Act); section 775.082 and section 775.083 (penalties).
- Williams v. State, 125 So. 3d 113 (Fla. 2013) (juries must be instructed on section 812.025), quoting Hall v. State, 826 So. 2d 268 (Fla. 2002).
- Related reading on this site: Organized Retail Theft in Florida; Drug Trafficking Charges in Florida.
This article is general information about Florida law as of November 17, 2026. Quoted statutory language is from the 2026 Florida Statutes as published by the Florida Senate; quoted case language is from the published opinions. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every person charged with a crime is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. Every case is different. A result in one case does not predict the result in another.